Old Fashioned Cream Soda

This old-time recipe is like being at an old fashioned soda fountain!

  • Servings: 8
  • Cook Time: 15 Min
  • Main Ingredient: Carbonated Water


  • 2 liters plain seltzer water
  • 2 tsp. pure vanilla extract
  • 4 packets SugarTwin® STEVIA Packet


Open 2-liter bottle of seltzer and pour out ½ cup to make room for soda flavor mixture. Add vanilla extract and SugarTwin® .Careful! The carbonated water will react 'excitedly' with the natural ingredients in flavor mixture. Allow for ingredients to mix with water and for some gas to be released from bottle prior to uncapping – by unscrewing cap just a small amount to hear 'hisses'. Pour over ice and enjoy! Using a 2 liter bottle of carbonated water, pour approximately a half cup of soda into a glass on the side, before pouring into the bottle the soda flavor mixture. Add to bottle vanilla extract and SugarTwin®. Tighten the cap and let mix, avoid shaking the bottle. Let some gas out of the bottle, then pour the mixture into a bowl of your favorite ice cream.